Identifying & Responding to Domestic Violence
Among Poor & Homeless
Women
by Sharon M. Melnick, Ph.D. and
Ellen L. Bassuk, M.D. | The Better Homes Fund
| February 2000
1. Trauma and Recovery A. Understanding
Trauma
People react to violence
and abuse in complex ways, often resulting in serious emotional and medical
consequences. Table 1 describes common symptoms of a psychiatric-medical
syndrome among trauma survivors called Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
PTSD involves the short and long-term effects of physical or sexual abuse as
well as other traumas.
| Table 1. Symptoms of PTSD |
| Intrusive Remembering |
Avoidance |
Hyper-arousal |
| |
•Flashbacks
|
Avoiding places,
people & conversations which are reminders of the trauma |
•Disrupted sleep |
| |
•Nightmares
|
•Difficulty
remembering parts of the trauma |
•Poor concentration |
| |
•Distress when
remembering trauma
|
•Emotional
constriction |
•Startle response |
| |
•Physiological
reactivity when remembering
|
•Feeling detached
from others |
•Anger outbursts |
| |
•Feeling the trauma
is happening again
|
•Feeling life is
destined to be unlucky or shortened |
•Hyper-vigilance
(feeling "on guard") |
B. Understanding
Recovery
Recovery is a long-term
process that is often highly individualized. Some clinicians believe recovery
occurs in three stages. In Stage 1, a survivor is often highly symptomatic.
She may need to establish a sense of safety, including care and control over
her body (basic health, food, sleep, exercise, avoiding drugs, etc.), create a
safe environment (non violent relationships), develop coping skills to manage
symptoms and high levels of distress, and attend to basic needs such as
housing. Homeless and low-income women in the first stage of recovery face
added instability and difficulty in establishing predictable and healthy
practices because of economic constraints.
After establishing
respectful relationships, an environment of stability, and an increased
ability to cope with her feelings, a survivor is ready to move on to Stages 2
and 3. These stages involve reconstructing what happened, understanding its
impact, and reconnecting with others around issues other than trauma. Table 2
summarizes the effects of trauma and goals for recovery (see page 2).
| Table 2: Effects of Trauma and Goals for Recovery |
| EFFECTS OF TRAUMA |
SHORT-TERM GOALS |
LONG-TERM GOALS |
| Relationships |
Relationships |
Relationships |
| |
•Mistrusts others
|
•Asks for help |
•Forms safe,
meaningful relationships |
| |
•Isolation/Disconnection
|
•Engages in safe
sexual practices |
•Extends feelings of
safety to others in relationships |
| |
•Aggressive towards
others
|
•Sees possibility to
trust some others |
|
| |
•Repeated
victimization
|
|
|
| Emotions |
Emotions |
Emotions |
| |
•Has intense emotions
(e.g. rage, fear)
|
•Identify and label
feelings |
•Can comfortably
experience a wide range of emotions |
| |
•Feel emotions
"too much"
(feels "taken over")
|
•Can "turn
down" negative emotions |
•Autonomously uses
affect tolerance techniques |
| |
•Feels emotions
"too little"(feels numb", uses drugs)
|
•Regulates feelings
with help of others |
•Free from harmful
numbing strategies |
| Conditions of the Body |
Conditions of the Body |
Conditions of the Body |
| |
•Panicked/anxious/"on
guard"
|
•Recognizes
"symptoms" as reactions to trauma |
•Has repertoire of
self-soothing techniques |
| |
•Sleep disturbances
|
•Is referred
for/engages in treatment for PTSD |
•Develops mastery
over symptoms |
| |
•"Body
memories"
|
•Can use breathing or
distraction to calm down |
|
| Feelings about Self |
Feelings about Self |
Feelings about Self |
| |
•Feels
"bad," "unworthy," "unlovable"
|
•Can ask for help
with minimal shame |
•Regularly practices
self-care |
| |
•Neglects health
|
•Does one nice thing
for herself |
•Feels positive about
herself and deserving of care |
| |
•Self-harm
|
•Decreases
self-harm/risky behaviors |
•Stops self
harm/risky behaviors |
| |
•Risky behaviors
|
|
|
| Not Feeling Whole |
Toward Feeling Whole |
Feeling Whole |
| |
•Dissociated/does not
"know" or "remember" parts of her reality
|
•Can become grounded
in current reality with help of others |
•Practices grounding
to prevent dissociation |
| |
•Remembers feelings
or memories, but not both
|
|
•Feels
"whole" |
| | |
|
•Makes connection
between past experiences and current feelings |
| | |
|
•Integrates memory
and affect |
| Memory |
Memory |
Memory |
| |
•Memories intrude at
times
|
•Can recognize
"flashbacks" as memories of traumatic experiences |
•Able to recall
memories at will |
| |
•No memory of parts
of life
|
•Interested in
learning how to "turn memories off" |
•Free from memory
intrusions |
| Spirituality/Worldview |
Spirituality/Worldview |
Spirituality/Worldview |
| |
•Sees world as unsafe
|
•Develops safe
relationship with provider |
•Draws
comfort/meaning from spirituality |
| |
•May lose faith
|
•Finds spiritual
beliefs that encourage recovery |
•Realistic sense of
hope for the future |
| |
•Hopeless
|
|
•Comes to terms with
painful past |
Back to Top
2. Building a Therapeutic Relationship
Studies of poor and
homeless women suggest that many believe health care providers are not safe,
trustworthy, or understanding. Because people have failed to protect them,
trauma survivors may feel alone and be slow to trust.
The foundation of all
therapeutic interactions is the relationship between the provider and the
client. The first step in helping trauma survivors is to establish a mutual
relationship built on trust, understanding, and respect. Providers can play an
essential role in a client's recovery by following the 4 C's: Connect;
Counter; Collaborate; and Coordinate.
A. Connect
Build trust by engaging
the client and making a positive connection. Listen to the client and validate
her experiences at every opportunity. Provide concrete help whenever possible:
•Inform her about the
process (who you are, your role, what you are doing, why you are doing it,
the limits of confidentiality, when you will invite others to intervene,
etc.).
•Be respectful,
straightforward, interested, and acknowledge your limitations.
•Make eye contact. Use
a compassionate and calm tone of voice.
•Always maintain
appropriate boundaries.
•Provide immediate aid
such as food or access to a telephone.
•Discuss safety issues
and, if necessary, make a safety plan (see Part IV).
•Address housing,
transportation, income support, and children's needs.
B. Counter Unrealistic
Beliefs
•Counter the client's
feelings of isolation and shame by showing that you are glad to see her and
are concerned about her. • Counter her view of herself by telling her she is
worthy and capable of feeling better. •Counter her worries that she may
be "going crazy" by helping her to recognize the effects of violence
may be involved in her current distress.
•Educate her about the
relationship between her symptoms and past traumatic experiences.
•Ask about "what
happened," not what is "wrong" with her.
•Reinforce strengths
you observe in the client.
•Show sensitivity to
the social and cultural context of her life.
•Maintain boundaries.
•Discuss any touching
of the client beforehand.
•NEVER use physical
force or restraints. These may traumatize the client by re-enacting abuse.
C. Collaborate
Empower the client to
be a partner in shared decision-making. Learn about her needs and wishes, and
collaborate with her in choosing services and referrals.
•Provide options for
treatment and referral. Talk with her about the information you will share
with her, how you will share it, and at what pace-even where she will
sit in the consultation room.
•Ask her about what she
sees as her most important needs. Create a list of realistic short- and
long-term priorities.
•Support her choices.
If she has survived horrendous circumstances, she has developed coping
mechanisms that work for her.
•Provide a sense of
hope that together you can find helpful services.
D. Coordinate
Coordinate services to
meet her basic needs as well as provide trauma-specific treatment. Help her
feel there is a safety net of concerned people who will support her during
recovery. Be a bridge until she engages in individual, group, or peer
treatment.
•Coordinate care with
different agencies.
•Show concern by
keeping in contact with other providers (with the client's permission
and involvement).
•Help her engage in
case management services.
•Develop a
peer-counseling network by connecting the client with others who have
experienced trauma.
Back to Top
3. Assessing and Identifying Trauma
A client's traumatic
experiences may not be apparent. It is important to gently interview all women
about trauma, and about their health and mental health conditions, even if
they do not seem distressed. Otherwise, they may be misdiagnosed. Assessing
and identifying trauma is not usually a linear process. The provider must take
cues from the client's verbal and nonverbal responses, and conduct the
interview accordingly. Understand the "whole" person. Learn about
the client's strengths as well as her problems.
A. Focus on the
Chief Complaint
Define the client's chief
complaints, precipitating events, and major medical and/or psychiatric
conditions. Understand what events or feelings immediately led up to the
person's visit to the clinic. Once you diagnose the client's medical and
psychological situation, prioritize treatment and service referrals in order
of urgency. Acute crises, in the form of out-of-control behaviors or
life-threatening medical conditions, are always the priority. Tables 3 and 4
describe common medical and emotional problems of trauma survivors.
| Table 3: Common Medical Conditions Found Among Trauma Survivors |
| ACUTE CONDITIONS |
CHRONIC CONDITIONS |
| |
•Acute injuries
(contusions, sprains, minor lacerations, fractures, abdominal injuries,
concussions, and gun shot wounds; also joint damage, scars.) Common
sites are head, face, neck, ears, vaginal area, anus, and areas covered
by clothing.
|
•Chronic injuries |
| |
•Blunt head trauma
(associated with unconsciousness, blurred vision, seizures, and
"rage reactions").
|
•
Chronic pain (in
pelvis, abdomen, back, breast, and muscles) |
| |
•Medical concerns
related to rape (gynecological trauma, risk of pregnancy, risk of HIV
and other STDs, rectal bleeding, and musculoskeletal or other injuries).
|
•Gastrointestinal
problems (e.g., irritable bowel syndrome, and stomach aches) |
| |
•Pregnancy problems
(miscarriages, placental separation, ante-partum hemorrhage, fetal
fractures, pre-term labor, and uterine rupture).
|
•Sexual dysfunction
(functional dyspareunia, sexual difficulties) |
| |
•Delayed prenatal
care-seeking
|
•Frequent vaginal and
urinary tract infections |
|
•Self-harm
(overdose, cutting). |
•Sexually
transmitted diseases |
|
•Physical symptoms
of panic (heart palpitations, dizziness, and nausea). |
|
| Table 4: Emotional Disorders and Problems Common Among Trauma Survivors |
| |
•Posttraumatic Stress
Disorder (PTSD)
|
•Self-Harm (overdose,
cutting) |
•Dissociative Fugue |
|
•Anxiety Disorders |
•Psychotic
Conditions |
•"Parts"
of the Person Controlled by Behavior |
| |
•Substance Abuse/
Dependence
|
•Suicidal Ideation or
Self-Harm |
•Loss of
Consciousness |
| |
•Major Depression
|
•Drug/Alcohol
Overdose |
•"Rage
Reactions" |
| |
•Dissociative
Disorders
|
•Panic Attacks |
• |
| |
•Somatization
Disorder
|
|
|
B. Look for Indicators
of Trauma
Observe the client and
listen carefully for indicators of possible trauma, both current and in the
past. Table 5 describes some of these indicators.
|
Table 5.
Indicators of Possible Trauma: Behavioral Styles You May Observe Among
Survivors |
| CONSIDER THE LIKELIHOOD THAT
A CLIENT HAS SURVIVED VIOLENCE IF SHE EXHIBITS ANY OF THE FOLLOWING
BEHAVIORS: |
Dissociation
A client has a blank or "faraway" look. She may exhibit a lack
of apparent distress when she is experiencing physical pain or
describing an intensely emotional situation (e.g., talks in monotone
voice as though she is disinterested, bored, or reading a script; she
may not cry).
Cause: Repeated intense feelings may have caused her
habitually to "check out" or "go away in her mind"
in order to not be overwhelmed. |
Fear/Anxiety/Mistrust A client is wary or
mistrustful of the provider. She may hesitate to answer questions or may
show signs of arousal/anxiety, jumpiness, nervousness, or
hyper-vigilance.
Cause: She may have been "on guard" all the time
to protect herself from someone who was hurting her. |
Feelings of Badness
A client treats herself as if she were "no good" or
"undeserving". She may neglect caring for her body, ask too
little of providers, believe she's never good enough, or feel deserving
of mistreatment by others.
Cause: She was told or she concluded from others' behavior
that she was "at fault" for past traumas. |
Refusing Help
A client appears "tough" or "hostile", or refuses
help.
Cause: She may have been so abused that it is painful to
feel vulnerable or to need help from anyone. |
Self-Harming
A client has scars on her arms or other body parts from hurting herself.
Cause: Hurting herself is a way of relieving the intense
pain of her feelings, or a way to feel alive instead of feeling
"numb." |
Demanding/Helpless
A client requires a lot of care or portrays herself as unable to take
control of her life.
Cause: This style may stem from not being taken care of
unless she was very demanding, or from repeatedly being powerless to
change frightening circumstances. |
C. Ask About Current
and Past Violence
When you talk with the
client, be sure she is alone. Never ask questions about abuse in front of a
boyfriend, chaperone, etc. If it is not possible to arrange for privacy,
postpone questioning for another visit. Work with clinic security officers to
develop protocols for situations when the person accompanying the client is
unwilling to provide privacy. When necessary, use a professional interpreter
or another provider fluent in the client's language. Do not ask a client's
family, friends, or children to interpret when asking about domestic violence
or incest.
Give the client as much
choice as possible about how to present her story. Pay attention to her
reactions and respond accordingly. Provide her with feedback.
•If a client indicates
a posttraumatic response, ask more questions to find out if she is
experiencing mistreatment either now or in the past.
•Many survivors are
likely to "relive" a traumatic experience as they talk about it.
Your client may become upset, or may dissociate and look blank. Check in
with her by asking if she is feeling overwhelmed.
•If a client has
"checked out," use grounding techniques to help her orient
herself. See Table 6 for a description of grounding techniques. Check in
with the client at the end of your time together. Make sure she is aware
of her surroundings, able to keep herself safe, and can tell you what she
is going to do in the next few hours. Explain that it is normal for her to
react to your discussion for a period of time after your visit. Few interview instruments
are designed for homeless and low-income women. One instrument specifically
modified to be sensitive to these women--and used by many Health Care for the
Homeless clinicians--is the "Posttraumatic Diagnostic Scale Modified for
Use with Extremely Low Income Women." To obtain the questionnaire,
contact The Better Homes Fund : 181 Wells
Ave, Newton Centre, MA 02459;Tel: 617-964-3834; Fax: 617-244-1758; dawn.moses@tbhf.org.
|
Table 6. Grounding
Techniques |
|
Grounding Techniques are
strategies to help a person who is dissociating "come back" into
current reality and feelings. Grounding techniques help the person become
aware of the here and now. A useful metaphor may be "walking out of a
movie theatre." When the person is dissociating or having a
flashback, it is like watching a mental movie (more like an extended
nightmare). Grounding techniques help the person step "outside the
movie theatre" into the "light of day" and "present
environment." Their task is to hold onto the shattered moments from
the past, but also to realize that what they were experiencing was
"only a movie." |
| 1. State what you observe:
"You look like you are feeling very scared/angry right now. You are
probably feeling things related to what happened in the past. Now you are
in a situation where no one is hurting you. Lets try to stay in the
present-- take a slow deep breath, relax your shoulders, put your feet on
the floor, let's talk about what day and time it is, let's notice what's
on the wall around us, etc. What else can you do to try to feel okay in
your body right now?" |
| 2. Techniques to help the
client decrease the intensity of her affect:
•"Emotion
dial:" a client imagines turning down the volume on her emotion
•Clenching fists to
move energy of emotion into fists and then release
•Guided imagery to
visualize a "safe place"
•Distraction (see
below) |
| 3. Techniques to use external
stimulation to distract from unbearable emotional states:
•Focus on external
environment.
•Focus on recent
and future events (e.g., "to do" list for the day).
•Self talk to
remind oneself of current safety.
•Use distraction,
such as counting, to return to focus on current reality.
•Somatosensory
techniques (wiggle toes, touch a chair) to remind of current reality.
•Holding ice, wet
facecloth, running hands under cold water. |
| 4. Deep Breathing
•Inhale through
nose, exhale through mouth.
•Place hands on
stomach, watch hands go up and down as belly expands/contracts. |
D. Respond
Compassionately
Believe the client and
validate her experiences. Many survivors who have confided in family members
or other trusted figures have been disbelieved, blamed, shamed, told to
"get on with life," or told they are "crazy." When you say
to a client that emotional and physical violations are/were undeserved and
wrong, you may help a survivor feel more worthy of self-protection and
respect.
Try to understand the
effects of the client's disclosure from within her social context. Social
norms about what is considered violent or violating differ across cultures.
Important social figures within the extended family or community may have
critical influence over the individuals involved in the violence. Encourage
the client to define her own culture and community, and try to understand the
beliefs of this culture.
Back to Top
4. Making a Safe Plan "Safety" has
different meanings for different people. Women who have experienced extreme or
sadistic traumas, or who have lived under conditions of poverty, psychiatric
labeling, or violence experience their world as fundamentally and pervasively
"unsafe." It is important for caregivers to provide direct,
practical, and concrete help on the basis of what the woman says she needs,
rather than on the caregiver's notion of "safety."
A. Immediate Safety
Ask the client about
current dangers she faces. Imminent dangers may include battering, abuse,
rape, threats of violence to herself or her children, or return to a
psychiatric institution where she was restrained or put in seclusion. A
pregnant woman may be at especially high risk for partner violence. If the
client is in danger of being hurt, then make a Safety Plan (see Table 7).
|
Table 7. Making a
Safety Plan |
In situations where abuse is
ongoing, a Safety Plan should be developed to keep the client and her
children safe from harm. The most dangerous time for a woman in a violent
relationship is the period immediately after she leaves. Thus, it is
extremely important for a woman to think through her plans carefully and
to consider the consequences of her plans. For women to successfully
leave, she must have various supports and resources in place. |
A Safety Plan includes, but is
not limited to, problem-solving with the client about the following
topics:
•Where will you go?
Do you have friends/family or is there a shelter that could provide
safety?
•If you go back to
your partner/unsafe situation how will you escape if violence happens
or you feel threatened again? How will you maintain your emotional
safety and self-care in the context of ongoing danger?
•How will you
prepare your personal belongings and important papers you'll need if
you had to leave your shelter/home immediately?
•How will you
arrange to keep copies of important papers and an extra set of clothes
at a trusted place or with someone you trust?
•Do you know how to
contact the police to obtain a protective restraining order? Do you
need legal assistance or immigration counsel?
•How will you make
arrangements for your safety at work or in public places? |
B. Self-Injurious,
Suicidal and Homicidal Thoughts
Trauma survivors are at
higher risk for self-harming behavior as a way to manage overwhelming
feelings, discharge tension, communicate important messages to others, attempt
self-purification, or for a variety of other reasons.
When survivors begin to
acknowledge the full extent of their betrayals, they frequently express a wish
to die and may attempt suicide. The most important risk factors for suicide
include having made past attempts, feelings of hopelessness, and having a
detailed plan with intention to act and the means to carry out the plan. A
client is most at risk for self-harm when her depression is improving because
she has more energy and an improved capacity to think through her actions. The
provider should ask all survivors about suicidal or homicidal feelings.
C. Crisis Planning
If the client is in
danger of hurting herself, talk with her about crisis planning to prevent harm
to herself or others.
•Validate her
experiences and work together to discover other ways she can cope with and
express her feelings. Find out if there is anyone with whom she discusses
her feelings.
•Help the client
develop strategies to prevent or distract her from acting on
self-destructive thoughts. Examples include: spending time with a friend
instead of being alone, calling a Help Line, seeking the company of people
she trusts, or going to a place where she doesn't fear being hurt.
•Discuss alternatives
for containing and expressing intense emotional states such as vigorous
exercise, baths, long walks, screaming, artwork, writing in a journal,
listening to music, watching TV, or stretching.
•Ask her if she has
reasons for living. Help her acknowledge reasons to stay alive.
•Make a specific time
to "check in" with her about how she is feeling.
•If a client says that
she is unable to care for herself or keep herself safe, help her find a
place where she can be safe. Consider options for how she might stay in
her own home with some assistance.
•Refer the client to
trauma-specific clinical services when appropriate. Continue to monitor
her closely until she has made the transition to appropriate clinical
care.
Back to Top
5. Treating a Traumatized Client A. Managing Acute
Crises
Symptoms exhibited by a
person suffering from a trauma-related psychological condition or substance
abuse can intensify to the point of crisis:
•Some survivors with
trauma-related psychological difficulties may also have a major mental
illness, while others who appear to be psychotic are inaccurately
diagnosed. They may be experiencing severe dissociative states in which
what they say sounds bizarre or grotesque but reflects memories or
reenactments of real experiences they have endured or witnessed.
•Trauma-related intense
emotional states are scary for a survivor. She may feel "taken
over" and appear out of control.
•A client in a
dissociative fugue state loses memory for significant amounts of time
leading up to the medical visit and may not be aware of who or where she
is.
•Medical problems may
be secondary to drug/alcohol intoxication, suicide attempts, or other
self-harming behaviors.
B. Assisting Clients
in an Emotional Crisis
A combination of
supportive and directive interviewing is most effective when dealing with a
client in an emotional crisis. The goal of crisis intervention is to: (1)
ensure the safety of client and staff, (2) address the client's immediate
distress and identify what has triggered it, and (3) restore the person to her
maximal level of functioning.
Supportive
Interviewing
•Act professionally
(identify your role, maintain appropriate boundaries). Treat the client
respectfully.
•Ask about, label, and
validate her feelings.
•Appeal to the client
to use techniques for self-calming that have worked for her in the past.
•Use grounding
techniques to help reorient the client, if necessary (see Table 6).
•Never use coercive
restraints, force, or threats.
•Use sedative
medications as a last resort and only if the client agrees.
Directive Interviewing
•Help the client to
understand the nature and purpose of your interaction. Ask concrete,
simple, closed-ended questions.
•Help her "reality
test" by gently correcting her misperceptions.
•Set limits in a firm,
straightforward manner, but do not act challenging.
•Provide choices for
how to bring behavior and feelings under control.
•Set positive
expectations to show that you believe the client can regain control.
C. Use of Medication
Some medications are
useful for treating and relieving trauma-related conditions. Psychotropic
medications should only be prescribed by a psychiatrist who is familiar with
the gender-specific psychopharmacology of trauma. A careful evaluation of past
history and current health with special attention to a history of substance
abuse should be conducted before medications are prescribed. Many psychotropic
medications are addicting and women are generally more sensitive to medication
levels. The following medications can sometimes be helpful for clients with
severe trauma reactions:
•Antidepressant
medications, especially the newer SSRIs, have been shown to decrease some
numbing and hyper-arousal symptoms, and help clients manage intense
emotions.
•Desyrel ® (Trazadone) is an
antidepressant that sometimes reduces sleep disruptions. It may be given
alone or together with antidepressants that may cause insomnia.
•Benzodiazepines are
sometimes prescribed for panic and anxiety-related insomnia.
•Neuroleptics should be
used extremely cautiously for clients with trauma-related disorders
because there is no evidence to support their utility and they may have
serious side effects. If the client is having psychotic symptoms, it is
important to rule out the possibility that the "hallucinations"
are flashbacks or dissociative states that express feelings/memories of
"alter" personalities.
Back to Top
6. Specialized Treatment
Work with the client to
develop a mutually agreeable treatment plan. Discuss options in a simple,
straightforward manner. Support her decisions and choices. Try to match your
client's needs with available services.
•Determine the support
your client needs and refer her for appropriate services (e.g., outpatient
treatment, residentially based programs, 12-step meetings, detox,
counseling, etc.).
•Encourage use of peer
support groups, peer networks, and self-help groups.
•Arrange for a case
manager to make linkages with services.
•Consider a
consultation for medication. Be extremely cautious in recommending
medications, especially if you do not know the client well. Be especially
conservative in cases of current violence, because medication may dull a
woman's preparedness or may be confiscated and sold by her perpetrator.
•For clients with
co-occurring conditions, the best treatments are those that simultaneously
address the effects of all conditions.
•Learn about
traditional and non-traditional treatment options and services in your
community. It may be useful to collect referral sources in your area,
computerize the list, and collate them into a brochure.
•Consider the woman's
ethnic identity and cultural context when making a referral. For
clients who are wary of service systems, or for clients who are immigrants
or whose native language is not English, it may be necessary to be more
proactive about making referrals.
Back to Top
7. Documenting and Reporting Violence
A. Documenting the
Effects of Violence
Thorough documentation of
a victim's injuries/complaints, etc. may provide important evidence if the
survivor needs legal support. Writing a clear note in the medical chart about
the effects of violence will alert future providers to the importance of the
client's history of trauma. Notes in the medical chart should include:
•Domestic violence
history, including present complaints or injuries. Include date, time, and
location of domestic violence incidents.
•Past experiences of
physical and sexual abuse, and frequency. When appropriate, use the
patient's own words in quotation marks.
•Client's injuries,
including type, location, size, color, and age. Document injuries on a
body map.
•Alleged perpetrator's
name, address, and relationship to patient (and children, if any).
•Legal steps taken by
the survivor to obtain restraining orders or to file suit against a
perpetrator.
•Other physical or
mental health problems that may be related to abuse.
•Details of your
intervention and all actions taken.
Whenever possible, and
with client's consent, take Polaroid photographs of injuries. Discuss the
client's feelings about photographs and the usefulness of this form of
documentation. If your site is not equipped to perform forensic exams, please
call a local Rape Crisis Center.
B. Reporting Abuse
Mandatory reporting
obligations differ by state. Health care providers should discuss reporting
policies at their respective clinics. A good source for reviewing state
statutes can be found in the Family Violence Prevention Fund's web site: http://www.fvpf.org and in the publication
entitled, Improving
the Health Care Response to Domestic Violence: A Resource Manual for Health
Care Providers.1
Produced by the Family Violence
Prevention Fund in collaboration with the Pennsylvania Coalition against
Domestic Violence. Written by Carole Warshaw, M.D. and Anne Ganley, Ph.D. with
contributions by Patricia Salber, M.D. Information is based on statutory law
as of 1994.
Back to Top
8. Caring for the Provider
Discussions with clients
about painful experience may trigger powerful emotions on the part of health
care providers. As with any experience that reminds a provider of prior
losses, dissatisfactions, or traumas, dealing with these reactions may prevent
interference with work and emotional well-being.
Providers who work with
clients who have been traumatized often experience an identifiable syndrome
that parallels the posttraumatic syndrome of the client. This is known as
"vicarious trauma" or "secondary PTSD." It includes
helplessness about not being able to "fix" or "help" the
client, hopelessness about being able to "make a difference," anger
over the brutality and injustice of the victimization, and guilt over not
being as distressed as the client. If not addressed, these common reactions
may result in decreased quality of job performance, demoralization, withdrawal
from colleagues, and exhaustion. Providers should develop a Self-Care Plan,
including:
•Establishing a
self-care routine by eating nutritiously, sleeping regularly, and
exercising.
•Finding a balance
between work and downtime by managing time effectively, and making time
for relaxation and enjoyable activities.
•Finding a sense of
meaning and mission in work by connecting with it spiritually and
participating in professional organizations.
•Establishing supports
for replenishment by having one's own therapy, staff support systems,
and continued training.
•Engaging in social
activism to bring about broader change by joining a professional
organization.
• Creating a sense of
"community" among colleagues.
Back to Top
9. References
Alien, J. (1999). Coping with
Trauma: A Guide to Self-Understanding. Washington, DC: American
Psychiatric Press, Inc.
Bassuk, E.L., Dawson, R.,
Perloff, J., Browne, A. (1999). PTSD in Extremely Poor Women: Implications for
Health Care Clinicians. Unpublished manuscript. The Better Homes Fund, Newton,
MA.
Bassuk, E.L., Melnick,
S., and Browne, A. (1998). Responding
to the needs of low-income and homeless women who are survivors of family
violence. Journal of the American Medical Women's Association, 53,
57-64.
Bassuk, E.L., Perloff,
J., & Garcia Coll, C. (1998). The
plight of extremely poor Puerto Rican and Non-Hispanic White Single Mothers.
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 33, 326-336.
Bassuk, E.L., Weinreb,
L., Buckner, J.C., Browne, A., Salomon, A., & Bassuk, S.S. (1996). The characteristics and needs of
sheltered homeless and low-income housed mothers. Journal of the
American Medical Association, 276, 640-646.
Bassuk, E.L. (1994). Community Care for Homeless Clients
with Mental Illness, Substance Abuse, or Dual Diagnosis. Newton, MA: The
Better Homes Fund.
Bassuk, S., Bassuk, E.L.,
Weinreb, L.F. (1999). Mental health and substance-related service use among
homeless and low-income mothers. Unpublished manuscript. The Better Homes
Fund, Newton, MA.
Browne, A. & Bassuk,
S. (1997). Intimate violence in the
lives of homeless and poor housed women: Prevalence and patterns in an
ethnically diverse sample. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 67,
261-278.
Browne, A & Finkelhor,
D. (1986). Impact of child sexual abuse: A review of the research. Psychological
Bulletin, 99, 66-77.
Davidson, J.R. & van
der Kolk, B. (1996). The psychopharmacological treatment of posttraumatic
stress disorder. In B. van der Kolk, A. McFarlane et al. (Eds.). Traumatic
Stress: The Effects of Overwhelming Experience on Mind, Body, and Society,
New York: Guilford Press, pp. 510-524.
Figley, C. (1995). Compassion
Fatigue: Coping with Secondary Traumatic Stress Disorder in Those Who Treat
the Traumatized. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Foa, E. (1995).
Posttraumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale Manual. Minneapolis, MN: National
Computer Systems Incorporated.
Fontes, L.A. (1995). Sexual Abuse in
Nine North American Cultures: Treatment and Prevention. Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications.
Gondolf, E. W. (1998). Assessing Woman
Battering in Mental Health Services. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Green, B. Epstein, S.,
Krupnick, J., Rowland, J. (1997). Trauma and medical illness: Assessing
trauma-related disorders in medical settings. In Wilson, J. & Keane, T.
(Eds.) Assessing
Psychological Trauma and PTSD. New York: The Guilford Press, pp 160-191.
Harvey, M. (1996). An
ecological view of psychological trauma and trauma recovery. Journal of
Traumatic Stress, 9, 3-23.
Harvey, M. (1996). The
Multidimensional Trauma Recovery and Resilience Scale. (MTRR). Unpublished
Instrument of the Victims of Violence Program, Cambridge Health Alliance.
Herman, J. (1992). Trauma and
Recovery. New York: Basic Books.
Herman, J., Perry, C.,
& van der Kolk, B (1989). Childhood trauma in borderline personality
disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry, 146, 490-95.
Himber, J. (1994). Blood
rituals: self-cutting in female psychiatric inpatients. Psychotherapy,
31, 620-631.
Jensvold, M, Halbreich,
U., & Hamilton, J. (Eds.) (1996). Psychopharmacology
and Women: Sex, Gender, and Hormones. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric
Press, Inc.
Kantor, G., Jasinski, J,
& Aldarondo, E. (1994). Sociocultural status and incidence of marital
violence in Hispanic families. Violence & Victims, 9, 207-222.
Kilpatrick, D., Acierno,
R., Resnick, H., Saunders, B., & Best, C. (1997). A 2-year longitudinal
analysis of the relationships between violent assault and substance use in
women. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65, 834-47.
Melnick, S.M., Tummala,
P., & Harvey, M. (1998). The Multidimensional Trauma Recovery and
Resilience Scale (MTRR): An Exploratory Factor Analysis. Poster presented at
the Annual Meeting of the International Society of Traumatic Stress Studies.
Najavits, L.M., Weiss,
R.D., Shaw, S.R. (1997). The link between substance abuse and posttraumatic
stress disorder in women. A research review. American Journal on Addictions,
6(4), 273-283.
Stark, E., Flitcraft, A.,
et al. (1981). Wife Abuse in the Medical Setting: An Introduction for Health
Personnel. Washington, DC: Office of Domestic Violence; Monograph 7.
Terr, L. (1990). Too Scared to
Cry. New York: Harper & Row.
The Better Homes Fund.
(1999) Worcester Family Research
Project (unpublished data). Newton, MA
van der Kolk, B.A.,
Burbridge, J., Suzuki, J. (1997) The psychobiology of traumatic memory:
Clinical implications of neuroimaging studies. In Yehuda, R., McFarlane, A.,
et. al. (Eds.) Psychobiology of Posstraumatic Stress Disorder. Annals of
the New York Academy of Sciences, 821, 99-113.
van der Kolk, B.A. (1996)
The body keeps the score: Approaches to the psychobiology of posttraumatic
stress disorder. In van der Kolk, B., McFarlane, A., et al. (Eds.). Traumatic
Stress: The Effects of Overwhelming Experience On Mind, Body, and Society.
New York: The Guilford Press, pp.303-327.
Warshaw, C. & Ganley,
A. (1998) Improving
the Health Care Response to Domestic Violence: A Resource Manual For Health
Care Providers, (2nd Ed.) Produced by the Family Violence Prevention Fund
in collaboration with the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
Recommended Readings
on Trauma:
Understanding the
Effects of Trauma
Grossman, F., Cook, A.,
Sepat, S & Konestan, K. (1999) With the
Phoenix Rising: Lessons from Ten Women Who Overcame the Trauma of Childhood
Sexual Abuse. Jossey-Bass, Inc.
Harvey, M. (1996). An
ecological view of psychological trauma and trauma recovery. Journal of
Traumatic Stress, 9, 3-23.
Herman, J. (1992) Trauma and
Recovery. New York: Basic Books.
van der Kolk, B.A.
(1996). In B. van der Kolk, B., McFarlane, A., Weisaeth, L. (Eds.). Traumatic
Stress: The Effects of Overwhelming Experience on Mind, Body, and Society.
New York: The Guilford Press, pp. 303-327.
Survivors in Their Own
Words
Bass E., Thornton L.
(1991). I
Never Told Anyone. Writings by Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse. New York:
Harper Perennial.
Blackshaw, L., Levy, A.,
& Perciano, J. (1999). Listening to High Utilizers of Mental Health
Services: Recognizing, Responding To and Recovering From Trauma. Oregon.
Mental Health and Developmental Disability Services Division, Office of Mental
Health
Children's Responses
to Trauma
Osofsky, J. (1997). Children in a
Violent Society. New York: The Guilford Press.
Terr, L. (1990). Too Scared to
Cry. New York: Harper & Row.
Goodman, L.A., Saxe, L.,
Harvey, M. (1991). Homelessness as psychological trauma. Broadening
perspectives. American Psychologist. 46, 1219-1225.
Domestic Violence
Warshaw, C. & Ganley,
A. (1998) Improving
the Health Care Response to Domestic Violence: A Resource Manual for Health
Care Providers, (2nd Ed.) Produced by the Family Violence Prevention Fund
in collaboration with the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
Dissociative Identity
Disorder
Putnam, F. (1989). Diagnosis and
Treatment of Multiple Personality Disorder. New York: The Guilford Press.
Back to Top
10. Acknowledgements
This publication was
developed in collaboration with the Health Care for the Homeless (HCH)
Clinicians' Network Research Committee. We would like to thank the committee
for their assistance and guidance with the project through its various phases.
We are deeply grateful to Jean Hochron, M.P.H, and Lori Marks, with the HCH
Branch, Bureau of Primary Health Care, for supporting this endeavor and making
it possible. The authors are also indebted to Laura Prescott, whose
thoughtfulness, sensitivity and perspective significantly improved the
publication. Without the dedication of Jennifer Perloff, M.P.A., Jean Brown
and Kim Taylor of The Better Homes Fund staff, this publication would not have
been completed.
Health Care for the
Homeless Clinicians' Network Research Committee:
Karen Rotondo, B.S.N.,
R.N.
Committee Chair
Executive Director
Department of Community Health
Mercy Hospital, Springfield, MA
Magda Barini-Garcia,
M.D., M.P.H
Chief Medical Officer
HIV Education Branch, HIV/AIDS Bureau
Jeanne Ciocca, M.S.W.,
A.C.S.W.
Special Projects Coordinator
Philadelphia Health Care for the Homeless Project
Ed Farrell, M.D.
Medical Director
Colorado Coalition for the Homeless
Back to Top
|